Published in Journal of Clinical Oncology, Vol 29. No. 24. (August 20), 2011: pp.3328-3330
Harold J. Burstein, Pamela B. Mangu, Mark R. Somerfield, Deborah Schrag, David Samson, Lawrence Holt, Debra Zelman, and Jaffer A. Ajani
Objective: To update the American Society of Clinical Oncology Technology Assessment: Chemotherapy Sensitivity and Resistance Assays (CSRA) published in 2004.
Methods: An Update Working Group reviewed data published between December 1, 2003 and May 31, 2010. MEDLINE and the Cochrane Library were searched. The literature search yielded 11,313 new articles. The limits for “human and English” were used and then standard ASCO search strings for RCTs, meta-analyses, guidelines, and reviews were added, yielding 1,298 articles for abstract review. Of these, only 21 met predefined inclusion criteria and underwent full text review and 5 reports of RCTs were included for data extraction.
Results: Review of the literature does not identify any CSRAs for which the evidence base is sufficient to support use in oncology practice.
Recommendations: The use of chemotherapy sensitivity and resistance assays to select chemotherapeutic agents for individual patients is not recommended outside of the clinical trial setting. Oncologists should make chemotherapy treatment recommendations on the basis of published reports of clinical trials and a patient’s health status and treatment preferences. Because the in-vitro analytic strategy has potential importance, participation in clinical trials evaluating these technologies remains a priority.
To discuss this guideline, visit the
ASCOconnection.org Practice forum. Log in with your asco.org username and password to comment.
The practice guideline is not intended to substitute for the independent professional judgment of the treating physician. Practice guidelines do not account for individual variation among patients and may not reflect the most recent evidence. The guideline does not recommend any particular product or course of medical treatment. Use of the practice guideline and summary is voluntary. The full practice guideline and additional information are available at http://www.asco.org/guidelines.
Updated: 9/6/11